Antdony`s Coal Fired Pizza in Altamonte Springs

Was told this pizza was the greatest unfortunately I never had a chance to try it.I ordered from Anthony’s website for delivery about 5:15 for delivery at 6:00 but never received it.I called Anthony’s twice and was told they gave it to a door dash delivery man and were notResponsible after that. They said they had no way of tracking the delivery guy to find out what happened Also said another customer had called with the same complaint.Very disappointed that they do not take any responsibility for the delivery.I had already paid for the pizza so I am out not only the pizza but the money.Lesson learned never order again.

I stumbled across this place leaving Altamonte mall. They said they recently remodeled and it looked like an awesome spot for lunch. I placed my order where i had mentioned that it was my first time there. The manager brought me a sample of the meatballs to try while my food cooked. The pizza i ordered was delicious! It is a little weird they do spots of sauce instead of spread it across the dough, but its delicious none the less. Small beer selection but thats ok because the food is so good you almost dont want to wash away the flavor with a drink! After the great service and food i can confidently say ill be back.

Did not have a good experience, Granted I did order pizza at 9:15pm which would be 45 minutes before they close.The bottom of the pizza was scorched(yes I understand coal fired, however this was burnt and bitter).the restaurant was definitely closed by the time I return home, Definitely did not have enough effort to even drive 20 minutes away to bring it back Even if they were open.I have had good experiences at this location, unfortunately this was not one of them.Update: Austin Blitz the manager is a great guy, He has restored my faith in this location and has true compassion for patrons who receive a bad experience doing his best to make it right.The definition of good customer service my friend, thanks again.

It was our 2nd time in this place, we really love their pizza. Place is very clean, I love the pictures in the bathrooms. We ordered wings and large pizza with three toppings and it came out very fast, so that was nice! Everything tasted amazing. Guy that was our server was also nice and funny.

Just too many great things to say. First off the staff here is amazing and polite and care, which you can also see why is the manager here. Austin was just amazing and awesome in truly caring about service and care. I’ve worked in the hospitality business for 20 years and sadly you see a decline in customer service. THIS IS NOT THE CASE HERE. You can immediately tell by the atmosphere there because the way Austin and his team relate with customers. Rarely see the genuine respect and care that Austin gave us. Will be back tons and look foreword to going back to the service that was given. Austin deserve a huge recognition and it shows in there. Couldn’t be more thankful, this IS WHO AND WHAT should be training and moving restaurants like this forward in the future. Thank you so much again AUSTIN!

This food was everything and I thoroughly enjoyed every bite. The chicken wings were delicious and the carmelized onions were an extra bonus. The pepperoni was delicious and had the perfect "3 C" combination char, crispiness and chew. Would definitely recommend and will be going back again.

The best pizza I’ve found in Central Florida after many searches. If you love a nice thin charred crust you will go nuts over this place. Also has a great bar with a nice rotation of local and regional brews.

not only is the pizza excellent the service provided by Gabriela is superior as well she is amazing loves what she does and has an excellent attitudewe come back for her and the pizza

Really good pizza. Clean and nice sit down restaurant and bar. The original wings are very flavor filled, they do not have dipping sauces to choose from. Carnivori pizza was great, careful though, we lost a few meatballs to the floor.

If you are anywhere near this area you must try Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza. Staff is so friendly and the pizza was amazing. Was here on business and found this place by accident. I will find a reason to come back.

The manager Austin And his team were great to work with in providing food to the COVID floor at the local hospital! Everything was clean and sanitized; not to mention the food was absolutely delicious! Austin went above and beyond and showed tremendous respect and appreciate for the work being done at the hospital. I would Higher recommend for any catering event. Thank you Austin for making our small celebrations a success.

On 4/19/2020, my boyfriend and I had lunch at this cute, very authentic styled restaurant. Our food was ordered and served fast, hot, and so deliciously! Our server was so kind, helped us decide what to order as we were new to this pizzeria, and was thorough with checking in and making sure we had what we needed. After our amazing meal, we had the unfortunate luck of a broken down vehicle. Our waitress, went out of her way to bring us ice cold waters, and even offered a helping hand with my car troubles. This is probably the most outstanding customer service experience I’ve encountered ever! Thank you young lady for your kindness, for going above and beyond your job description, and just overall being you! You are truly amazing! This woman needs a raise! Stay blessed and thank you again for making my day!

First time at this location and was very pleased with the food and service! Out salad, wings, Mediterranean pizza and chocolate cake were all delicious! Our server was also friendly. Nice atmosphere and a clean restaurant overall. Definitely will be back!👍

Ordered 30 min before close via uber eats and they canceled my order. Obviously cause it was too close to closing time. 5-10 min before closing time acceptable. But not 30. Never ordering from here again

This is such an elegant place and the staff were extremely nice, The only thing the would make this place even better and for me to actually eat here is if they had vegan options. But other than that this pizzeria had such a nice a wonderful atmosphere.♡

Exceptional spot to eat some food when in a rush. Their customer service is quick, pricing is affordable, great vibes. Would recommend to others

This was my favorite place to get pizza and wings! But withing the last year the quality of the food has gone way down. We don't even order the wings anymore because they're just gross now and we now have to order the pizza "well done" when it used to come that way without asking... but even when we ask we get soggy floppy pizza. We've called, we've had things remade only to be disappointed by the recook. I'd like to know what happened. Today will be my last time at this pizza place.

This place is a gem!! Try the meatballs they are the best in town. The pizza sauce is the true hero. The Food is top quality and it won't hurt the wallet.

Great place great food friendly staff. Had my 5 year old with me and the manager Austin gave him dough to play with and a cookie. Server Gabby was knowledgeable and friendly. Been coming for years and love it.

Love their pizza and meatballs! Fresh ingredients bring the flavor to life. Great service and good folks working there.

I've been here before and really like there pizza. There pizza is really light, not greasy, and never saugy in the middle. Tonight, I had the pepperoni and mushrooms 12" traditional which comes out to 6 slices each. I'm not sure if it is their tomato sauce on the pizza or what but it has a little spice to it which is different.

Amazing pizza. Coal fired pizza is a must try. I ordered online and picked up in the store. They have a special on Wednesdays that comes with wings which are also good.

LOVE my PIZZA ... Had to give you 4 STARS.PIZZA was good. Cheese, sauce, dough was Very good, BUT with most COAL Fired ovens... Will cook AND Dry out pizza crust / Dough rather quickly. Not a fan of dried out / OR / crispy dough. This is COAL fired pizza joint. Decor was warm and inviting. Menu had extensive Micro Beer selection.

I almost never write reviews, if ever. BUT I felt it was necessary for me to go out of my way to say that I had amazing service my first experience here. Food was delicious! Service was amazing! And the manager, Austin, made sure everything operated extremely smoothly. I was thoroughly impressed with how my experienced turned out. I will most definitely be back. If you’re reading this, go get yourself some pizza from this place!!!

I went to this location on Sunday January 12 and let me start by saying the food and service was outstanding!! My server was Angelina. She was friendly, nice, knowledgeable of the menu, and just overall superb. Upon finding out that I was a first time guest, the manager Austin brought us an order of the home made meatballs for free! He was also very friendly, welcoming, and was great at his job. He was speaking to almost every table ensuring they were having a good time.Now for the important part; the food. The meatballs were moist and flavorful while the sauce balanced with them perfectly. We had a plain cheese pizza which was to DIE for. The slightly charred crust mixed with dollops of sauce was a perfect combo. Overall this location and its staff seem to be doing very well. I will definitely be back.

Went in to get lunch. Nice place. Employees were wearing masks and gloves which is great during the pandemic. Was asked if it was my first time, said yes, and received free meatballs hand delivered by manager. Overall happy with my visit and will be back.

My favorite pizza place hands down! My son actually told me how good it was so I had to try! I’m so glad I found out about it! I only wish they offered garlic bread. Hopefully one day!